Why western liberals have long picked the wrong historical hero | Kenan Malik

A newly discovered text shows how the battles of the past are still being fought today

Lost in the library of a small American college has lain a text by one of Englands foremost philosophers that no one knew he had written. Reasons for tolerateing Papists equally with others, a work by the early Enlightenment philosopher John Locke was discovered in the archives of St Johns College in Annapolis, Maryland, by the independent scholar JC Walmsley. The find, announced last week, has been greeted with excitement by both philosophers and historians. It is significant, too, in throwing light upon political debates that have as much relevance now as they did 400 years ago.


Recommended For You

vTail Manifesto

Complete done-for-you resource kit, providing the fastest path to income using the reseller royalties addon. Includes done for you resources and training in multiple media.

SociVideo Jukebox Pro

SociVideo Jukebox Pro - The app the schedules its own queue and gives unlimited, free traffic while delivering big value!


Locke is central to modern politics because of his foundational role in liberalism. His Two Treatises on Government was highly influential in the development of liberal democracy. A Letter Concerning Toleration, published in 1689, is a key text in furthering notions of free speech and religious toleration. Both works shaped the thinking of Thomas Jefferson and other leaders of the American Revolution and underlay their commitment to the separation of church and state.

The proper concern of government, Locke argued in A Letter Concerning Toleration, is the protection of life, liberty, health and property. The state should not be concerned with an individuals religious beliefs or his means of salvation.

Written at a time when Europe was rent by religious strife, and when intolerance and persecution were the norm, it was a powerful argument for religious freedom. It was, however, also a narrow conception of liberty. Lockes aim was to extend freedom of worship to nonconformist Protestant congregations. Neither Catholics nor atheists were, in his view, deserving of tolerance, the former because they gave their allegiance to a foreign prince (the pope), the latter because their opinions were contrary to the preservation of civil society.

And here lies the significance of the newly discovered document. Written some 20 years before A Letter Concerning Toleration, its very title cuts against the grain of much of what we know of his thought.

If Papists can be supposd to be as good subjects as others, he writes, they may be equally tolerated. This has led many scholars to suggest, like Walmsley, that Locke was much more tolerant in certain respects than was ever previously supposed.

That seems doubtful. What the new manuscript shows was that Locke was aware of the arguments for religious freedom being extended to Catholics but in his published work he rejected them. Catholics were not as good subjects as others because their beliefs threatened society and so had to be excluded.

John Locke (16321704). Photograph: Stock Montage/Getty Images

This blindness to the meaning of tolerance was not peculiar to Locke. The question of what, and who, should be tolerated has been a fraught issue for liberal thought over four centuries. Today, anti-Catholic bigotry has largely faded. But Jews and, more recently, Muslims have faced the same argument that once applied to Catholics that they have a dual loyalty and that their beliefs threaten society.


Recommended For You

(Private) SyndLab Pro

LIVE Case Study: Page 1 Rankings For BOTH Video and Niche Sites Made EASY With Automatic Social Syndication!

X-Wave Agency Upgrade - Yearly

- Unlimited HD Renders - Monthly Real Estate Templates - Monthly Video and Motion Graphic Designs - Monthly Additional Music Tracks - UNLIMITED High Res Renders - Vertical and Square Video Finish

Google Maps Customizer - WordPress Plugin - WP Nearby Places Reseller

Reseller rights to sell PRO and keep 100% of the profit!


Today, too, the question of what we should tolerate is as contested as it was in Lockes time. From sedition to hate speech, from fake news to the giving of offence, there is a plethora of arguments about the need to constrain speech so as not to harm society, arguments that are often as hollow as Lockes.

The Enlightenment thinker who adopted a truly liberal attitude towards toleration was not Locke but the Dutch philosopher Baruch Spinoza, whose work is far too little known, especially in the Anglophone world.

Locke, as the historian Jonathan Israel has sketched out in a series of monumental books, was a key figure of the mainstream Enlightenment, while Spinoza was a guiding light of the radical wing. The mainstream, Israel suggests, was constrained in its ability to critique laws and conventions by its intellectual and social timidity. The radical Enlightenment was far less willing to compromise its beliefs about toleration, democracy and equality.

This distinction is particularly visible on the question of freedom of expression. The less freedom of judgment is granted to men, Spinoza said,the further are they removed from the most natural state and consequently the more repressive the regime. Involvement by the state, he insisted, should be restricted to mens actions, with everyone being allowed to think what he wishes and say what he thinks. It is a view that seems startling even today.

So, let us celebrate a great historical find in the new Locke manuscript. But if we want to address questions of tolerance we would do far better to look to Spinoza than to Locke.

Kenan Malik is an Observer columnist

Original Article : HERE ;

This post was curated & Posted using : RealSpecific

Thank you for taking the time to read our article.

Interested in building a blog or auto-blog like this one ? Or just want to order one ?  Join our "Blogging Tips Tricks and Resources Skype" Group and let's chat about it. 

Join "Blogging Tips Tricks and Resources Skype" HERE

Interested in Starting your own Roku TV Channel ? Or interested in learning how to build one ? Join our "Roku TV Channel Development" Skype Group and let's chat about it. 

Join "Roku TV Channel Development" HERE


If you enjoyed our content, we'd really appreciate some "love" with a share or two.

And ... Don't forget to have fun!



Nano Video Hosting and Live Streaming - 50GB

Video hosting and live streaming service, including unlimited bandwidth, True TV and VOD.

Special Repwarn Resellers Monthly Account

Repwarn Resellers Account Monthly Subscription. Allowing you to sell Repwarn Software.

Leave a Reply